Not enough black voices in football? - The commentators take on racism

By Ricardo Chambers & Donald Oliver July 09, 2020

Only one lead black commentator was a part of a recent study which highlighted racial bias in football commentary in Europe. 

Danny McLoughlin, lead researcher for the study done by RunRepeat in partnership with the Professional Footballers' Association says black voices aren't represented enough in football commentary. 

McLoughlin, who was speaking on The Commentators podcast with Ricardo Chambers and Donald Oliver, said the study should have also made note of the lack of black commentators.

McLoughlin says he has received positive reactions from different stakeholders including commentators, but he believes media bosses are the ones who have to enforce the change

Last week, the findings of a study which looked into racial bias in football commentary were released, and needless to say, it raised a few eyebrows.

The study analyzed more than two thousand statements from commentators in matches during the current 2019/2020 season. 

The study was to determine if there was a difference in the way media speaks about players of different skin colour. One striking example had to do with commentators speaking about a player’s intelligence.

In 63.33% of instances where there was a criticism of a player’s intelligence, a player with darker skin tone was the target, while whenever there was praise, 62.60% of that praise was aimed at players with a lighter skin tone.

Related items

  • Rumour Has It: Declan Rice eyeing Man Utd move Rumour Has It: Declan Rice eyeing Man Utd move

    Declan Rice may be looking to make a move to Manchester United from resurgent West Ham. 

    The 22-year-old midfielder talked to United players during last month's international break as England won their opening three World Cup qualifiers.

    The Red Devils could be in need of midfield help if Paul Pogba leaves at the end of the season.

     

    TOP STORY - RICE TO RED DEVILS

    England international Declan Rice is interested in swapping West Ham for Manchester United, the Manchester Evening News reports. 

    During the recent international break, he spoke with Harry Maguire and Luke Shaw about the atmosphere at the club. 

    Rice is under contract with the Hammers through to 2024 but could be prised away for the right price. 

    David Moyes has said Rice could net £100 million for the London club. 

     

    ROUND-UP

    - Barcelona have made prolific Borussia Dortmund striker Erling Haaland their primary transfer target, according to Marca. Barca are willing to wait until the end of next season to get their man.

    - Brest defender Romain Perraud has the attention of Leeds United and Lyon, according to the Daily Mail. Perraud would shore up the defence of either club while serving as a potential asset going forward; he has three goals and six assists this season.

    - Goal reports Jesse Lingard is yet to decide whether he wants to make West Ham his permanent home as he continues to enjoy a stunning spell on loan from Manchester United.

    - Lyon center back and Danish international Joachim Andersen, currently on loan to Fulham, is drawing interest from Tottenham and Manchester United, B.T. reports, with Chelsea, Leicester City and Crystal Palace also potential destinations.

    Charles De Ketelaere may be on the move from Bruges, with Milan and Atalanta both potential landing spots, according to Calciomercato. 

  • Adelaide United 3-1 Macarthur: Reds into second after stylish victory Adelaide United 3-1 Macarthur: Reds into second after stylish victory

    Adelaide United moved into second in the A-League after a 3-1 win over Macarthur at Coopers Stadium on Wednesday.

    The Reds, beaten 4-0 in the previous meeting on February 12, produced a far slicker performance as they made it six wins out of eight at home.

    Tomi Juric headed in Craig Goodwin's cross after 15 minutes of Adelaide dominance before Matt Derbyshire's composed finish levelled the scores just past the half-hour mark.

    Goodwin restored the hosts' lead 72 minutes in, converting from the spot after being fouled by Lachlan Rose, before Ben Halloran made certain of the points with the goal of the game, a sublime backheel from Joshua Cavallo's delivery.

    Adelaide are just a point behind Central Coast Mariners at the top of the table, while Macarthur are fifth.

  • Rumour Has It: Man Utd in Ronaldo-Pogba swap deal with Juventus Rumour Has It: Man Utd in Ronaldo-Pogba swap deal with Juventus

    Cristiano Ronaldo's future beyond this season has been a hot topic of discussion.

    The 36-year-old Portuguese forward appears set to exit Juventus after three seasons in Turin, despite being contracted for another year.

    Ronaldo has been linked with former club Real Madrid and a switch to the United States, but there may be another option.

     

    TOP STORY – RONALDO IN UTD-JUVE SWAP DEAL

    Manchester United want to sign Cristiano Ronaldo this off-season and would consider a swap deal with Juventus for Paul Pogba, according to Calciomercato.

    Ronaldo played for United from 2003 to 2009 in the earlier part of his career, making almost 300 appearances for the Red Devils before his blockbuster move to Real Madrid.

    Pogba, who spent time at Juventus from 2012 to 2016, has also been the subject of transfer speculation.

    Juventus have this week been linked with a mega swap deal with United as they look for a transfer shake-up this off-season.

    ROUND-UP

    - The Independent reports Harry Kane's preference, if he was to leave Tottenham, is to remain in England and join either United or Manchester City.

    - Juve forward Paulo Dybala has attracted interest from Premier League pair United and Chelsea, claims Tuttosport.

    - United are also keen on an off-season move for Madrid defender Raphael Varane, according to The Mail. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's United have also been linked with Madrid captain Sergio Ramos, RB Leipzig centre-back Ibrahima Konate, Sevilla star Jules Kounde and Villarreal defender Pau Torres.

    - The Daily Mail reports Bayern Munich are bullish they can sign Borussia Dortmund sensation Erling Haaland as Robert Lewandowski's heir if he remains in Germany for one more season amid widespread interest this upcoming off-season. Haaland has been heavily linked with City, United, Madrid, Barcelona, Chelsea, Juventus and Paris Saint-Germain.

    - Arsenal midfielder Lucas Torreira is wanted by Argentine giants Boca Juniors, reports TyC Sports. Torreira is currently on loan at Atletico Madrid.

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.