Spurs sack Pochettino: Did Tottenham make the right decision?

By Sports Desk November 19, 2019

Tottenham have sacked Mauricio Pochettino, bringing an end to his five-year tenure in charge after a run of dismal results in the Premier League this season.

Three wins from 12 league matches have left Tottenham in 14th place, albeit only three points off fifth, while they also lost 7-2 to Bayern Munich in the Champions League last month.

Four successive top-four finishes and a Champions League final appearance will be Pochettino's lasting legacy and he also oversaw Tottenham's transition to a new, state-of-the-art stadium.

With the debate sure to continue over whether Spurs have made a harsh call, and plenty of speculation to come over who will replace him, two of our writers argue the case for and against Pochettino's sacking.

Tottenham have got it wrong - Tom Webber

Spurs defied expectations under the Argentinian and he underlined his status as an elite manager by leading them to the Champions League final last term.

While that game ended in defeat to Liverpool and left Pochettino without a trophy, their European run was combined with a fourth straight top-four finish, showing they had a leader capable of taking them to new heights.

However, their transfer business in the close season was a source of frustration for Pochettino, and he made no attempt to hide that.

While Tanguy Ndombele was a club-record signing from Lyon and Giovani Lo Celso provided another creative option in midfield, there were no other additions capable of immediately pushing the team forward.

Spurs let Kieran Trippier go and did not sign a replacement, leaving them exposed at right-back, while Danny Rose was seemingly retained against Pochettino's wishes.

By failing to give the 47-year-old the backing his work deserved, Spurs have now shot themselves in the foot twice and will only have themselves to blame if things go backwards from here.

Tottenham have got it right - Patric Ridge

Given what Pochettino has achieved during his time at Tottenham, the decision to cut ties seems a ruthless one when viewed in isolation, but that would not be taking into account what has been a dismal 2019 for Spurs on the domestic front.

In this calendar year, Tottenham have taken just 40 points from a possible 90 on offer in the Premier League, winning 11 matches, drawing a further seven and suffering 12 defeats.

Their poor form was, of course, masked by an incredible run to the Champions League final, but it is easy to forget Spurs were heading out in Amsterdam until Lucas Moura took matters into his own hands in a match that could easily have gone the other way.

Looking only at their league results this term, three wins from 14 league matches would be enough to get many managers in the top flight sacked. Why not Pochettino? 

While it is fair to say Tottenham did perhaps not back him as they should have done in the transfer market, the club did spend big. It is hard to imagine he did not have the final say on who was brought in.

Was a creative force such as Lo Celso, for example, strictly necessary when it was so obvious Tottenham lacked a quality right-back or alternatives up front – weaknesses that were exposed in humiliating fashion by Bayern last month?

The situation with Christian Eriksen has not helped, but again Pochettino must take his fair share of responsibility; looking back, any players dallying over signing fresh deals – see also Toby Alderweireld and Jan Vertonghen – have been ostracised during his time in north London. Is this the wisest approach when Tottenham have not had the squad depth to be able to cope with key players sitting idly by?

With the Premier League seemingly wide open – at least outside the top four – this season, Tottenham could not afford to delay any longer and, on the back of a five-match winless league run, they desperately need a fresh source of inspiration.

Related items

  • Championship: Hernandez the hero as Leeds take giant step closer to Premier League Championship: Hernandez the hero as Leeds take giant step closer to Premier League

    Pablo Hernandez fired Leeds United to the brink of a return to the Premier League as his late goal at Swansea City earned a priceless 1-0 win. 

    The former Swansea player came off the bench for the second half and scored in the 89th minute, sparking delight in the visitors' ranks. 

    Spanish midfielder Hernandez found the bottom left corner after Luke Ayling cut the ball back, just as Leeds looked like being frustrated. 

    Now they sit three points clear of second-placed West Brom and six ahead of in-form Brentford, who occupy third spot, and only three rounds of games remain. 

    Leeds have been absent from the top flight of English football since their relegation in 2004, which came just three years after a run to the Champions League semi-finals. 

    Veteran manager Marcelo Bielsa was persuaded to stay for this season, having gone agonisingly close last term to the elusive promotion. 

    Now, though, Leeds look ready to end their long wait, with games against Barnsley, Derby County and Charlton Athletic to come and a maximum of four points required. 

    The latest step on the road back to the elite came a day after the death was announced of one of their greatest players, England World Cup winner Jack Charlton, who spent his entire club career with Leeds. 

    Stoke City and Birmingham City have played Premier League football more recently than Leeds, but this season has been one of battling the threat of dropping into the third tier for both. 

    Stoke earned a 2-0 win over Birmingham on Sunday to join the Blues on 49 points, with both sides now four points clear of the relegation zone. 

    Beaten 5-0 by Leeds in their previous outing on Thursday, Stoke bounced back thanks to goals from Danny Batth and captain Sam Clucas.

  • Saka the surprise omission as Pepe starts for Arsenal in north London derby Saka the surprise omission as Pepe starts for Arsenal in north London derby

    Bukayo Saka is a surprise omission from the Arsenal starting XI as Nicolas Pepe is given the nod by Mikel Arteta for the north London derby. 

    Arsenal go to the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium just a point above their hosts, and both will be hoping for a victory to boost faltering bids for European football. 

    Arteta has once again chosen to go with the 3-4-3 formation that has largely proved dependable for the Gunners in recent weeks. 

    However, the talented Saka must be content with a place on the bench despite setting up Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang in the Gunners' 1-1 draw with Leicester City on Tuesday. 

    Saka has been a shining light for Arsenal this term, with the 18-year-old setting up 12 goals across all competitions this season. 

    Taking his place in the line-up is Pepe, who starts for the first time this month. After a shaky start, the Ivorian has gone on to have a relatively promising debut season with the Gunners, having a hand in 11 Premier League goals. 

    There are few surprises in the Tottenham team, with Lucas Moura and Son Heung-min joining Harry Kane in attack, while Tanguy Ndombele is left on the bench yet again – the Frenchman is yet to start a Premier League match since its resumption last month. 

  • Real Madrid's James gets warm birthday greeting from Zidane but remains out in the cold Real Madrid's James gets warm birthday greeting from Zidane but remains out in the cold

    Zinedine Zidane sent a warm birthday message to James Rodriguez by insisting the Colombian could play a part in Real Madrid's future – but then left him out of his latest squad.

    James, signed amid Galactico fanfare six years ago, has become almost a forgotten man with the Spanish giants, playing only a minor role in this season's LaLiga title charge.

    His 78-minute run-out against Real Sociedad in June was a first LaLiga appearance for James since October, and he has not played since.

    There are reports Madrid consider James superfluous to their needs and will look to sell him at the end of this campaign, with Manchester United among the clubs linked with him.

    Zidane struck a different tone in his news conference ahead of Monday's match against Granada, even wishing James well on the attacking midfielder's birthday.

    However, by later leaving James out of his 23-man squad for the Granada trip, the head coach's actions perhaps proved more telling than his words. 

    "He is important, and he is ours," Zidane told reporters.

    "He is 29 years old today and I congratulate him. It is true some play more and others less, but I will not look down on any player.

    "Everyone brings something to the team. I can count on all of those I have."

    James has just a year left on his Madrid contract and his influence has greatly diminished.

    Before this season, he spent two years on loan at Bayern Munich, winning a pair of Bundesliga titles but not doing enough to secure a permanent transfer.

    Signed from Monaco by Madrid in 2014 after a stellar World Cup, James was initially given the coveted number 10 shirt but now wears number 16, with his eight league appearances this season amounting to just 419 minutes on the pitch.

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.