Courtney Browne, Eldine Baptiste file suit against CWI for unfair dismissal

By May 06, 2019

Courtney Browne and Eldine Baptiste have filed suit against Cricket West Indies citing unfair dismissal from their jobs as West Indies selectors effective March 31, 2019.

Browne, a former Windies wicketkeeper, had been a member of the West Indies Selection Panel since 2010; Baptiste since 2014. Browne was being paid an annual salary of USD$71,000 with an annual telephone allowance of USD$6000. Baptiste was afforded a salary of USD$51,600 with an annual telephone allowance of USD$3600.

Both men were also entitled to a gratuity calculated at 10 per cent of their base salaries. According to a letter their attorneys – Thomas, John and Company that was addressed to Cricket West Indies CEO Johnny Grave, informing of the suit, both men claimed they had no other source of income and were financially dependent on the CWI.

The men said they received letters from the CWI on April 10, 2019, in which it was said that a task force was being established to review the selection system at all levels and that the task force was to make their recommendations to the board at their next meeting in June 2019.

However, without the task force having met, or made any recommendations to the board, they were informed that the selection panel was dissolved and that their services would not be required after March 31, 2019.

The letter to the CWI stated that the men do not accept the termination of their contracts of service “in accordance with the laws and particularly the Labour Code of Antigua and Barbuda on the grounds that notwithstanding the references to contractor and independent contractor in their respective contracts,” Browne and Baptiste, “were clearly employees under the Labour Code within the definition of employee and not independent contractors. Therefore they enjoyed the right under the Antigua Labour Law not to be unfairly dismissed.”

The lawyers for the plaintiffs also said their clients were and are not in business of their own and were not contracted as persons carrying on separate businesses but as persons required to personally perform their services under the contracts, and they could not under any circumstances subcontract or delegate any of their contractual services to any other person.

And, as it relates to their competency, the lawyers drew reference to evaluations that their clients were subjected to during their tenure. The evaluation forms referred to the men as “employees”.

In the most recent evaluations done in 2018, Browne was determined to be ‘excellent’ in the execution of his responsibilities by Director of Cricket Jimmy Adams, for “strict and uncompromising adherence to robust ethical ideals”.  Adams, in reference to Browne, was quoted in the evaluation as saying “He exhibits a high level of integrity in all he does.”

Baptiste was given the grade “Good” in his evaluation.

The lawyers representing the players claim that their clients believe that their termination was in part the result the CWI president’s inferences that they, Browne and Baptiste, were “part and parcel of and/or executed the old embedded selection policy which secretly, but actively victimized some players and banished them from selection consideration.”

Those “expressly and implicitly false” allegations from the president, the lawyers claim, were damaging to their clients.


Leighton Levy

Leighton Levy is a journalist with 28 years’ experience covering crime, entertainment, and sports. He joined the staff at SportsMax.TV as a content editor two years ago and is enjoying the experience of developing sports content and new ideas. At he is pursuing his true passion - sports.

Related items

  • Hundred price for Gayle was too high - Shane Warne Hundred price for Gayle was too high - Shane Warne

    T20 batting legend Chris Gayle might have priced himself out of the inaugural Hundred Draft held on Sunday.

  • India on the brink of a whitewash as Shami dismantles South Africa India on the brink of a whitewash as Shami dismantles South Africa

    South Africa are on the verge of suffering a 3-0 series defeat to India after they were reduced to 132-8 in their follow-on enforced second innings in Ranchi. 

    Having started day three of the final Test on 9-2, the Proteas were twice dismantled by India's rampant pace attack on Monday.

    Zubayr Hamza's knock of 62 was the best South Africa had to offer in their first innings, as they were bowled out for 162, 335 runs shy of India's total.

    Virat Kohli enforced the follow-on and India's pace attack - spearheaded by Mohammed Shami - once again made light work of the visitors' batting order.

    Theunis de Bruyn (30 not out), a concussion substitute for Dean Elgar, offered some resistance, though India need just two wickets to round off a dominant series triumph with South Africa still 203 runs in arrears.

    Things started as they would go on - South Africa captain Faf du Plessis (1) succumbing to a fine delivery from Umesh Yadav.

    Hamza, with assistance from Temba Bavuma (32), managed to steady the ship somewhat, and amassed his first Test 50 with a sublime six over mid-on.

    But Hamza's resistance was ended when, one delivery after he survived an India review, the 24-year-old was bowled by Ravindra Jadeja.

    Bavuma followed in the next over and, after Heinrich Klaasen (6) went before lunch, South Africa collapsed after the restart, losing four wickets for 33 runs.

    India were swiftly back on the wicket trail after enforcing the follow on - Yadav sending Quinton de Kock's (5) off-stump tumbling while Shami dismissed Hamza (0), Du Plessis (4) and Bavuma (0) in quick succession.

    Elgar was forced to retire hurt after he was clattered on the helmet by Yadav and, though his replacement De Bruyn held firm, the Proteas could not stem the flow of wickets - Dane Piedt (23) and Kagiso Rabada (12) offering nothing more than short-lived cameos.

  • Pakistan freshen up squad for Australia tour in wake of Sarfraz's sacking Pakistan freshen up squad for Australia tour in wake of Sarfraz's sacking

    Pakistan's squad has had a major shake-up for the upcoming tour of Australia, with five uncapped players named across the Test and Twenty20 parties.

    Sarfraz Ahmed was sacked as Pakistan's captain on Friday, with the wicket-keeper batsman also dropped from the squad following a dismal 3-0 T20 series defeat to Sri Lanka.

    Azhar Ali has taken over as the Test captain and will have teenage seamer Muhammad Musa Khan, who has been included in both touring selections, at his disposal.

    Experienced spinner Kashif Bhatti will also be available for Azhar, as will youngster Nasim Shah.

    Khushdil Shah and leg-spinner Usman Qadir, meanwhile, have been included in the T20 squad, which will be led by Babar Azam.

    Faheem Ashraf, Fakhar Zaman, the injured Hasan Ali, Shadab Khan and Mohammad Amir, who announced his retirement from Test cricket earlier in 2019, have all dropped out of the five-day squad, while Ahmed Shehzad and Umar Akmal miss out on the T20 group.

    Pakistan will play three T20Is and two Tests in Australia, with the tour beginning on November 3.


    Pakistan T20 squad in full: Babar Azam (captain), Asif Ali, Fakhar Zaman, Haris Sohail, Iftikhar Ahmed, Imad Wasim, Imam-ul-Haq, Khushdil Shah, Mohammad Amir, Mohammad Hasnain, Mohammad Irfan, Mohammad Rizwan (wicketkeeper), Musa Khan, Shadab Khan, Usman Qadir, Wahab Riaz.

    Pakistan Test squad in full: Azhar Ali (captain), Abid Ali, Asad Shafiq, Babar Azam, Haris Sohail, Imam-ul-Haq, Imran Khan, Iftikhar Ahmed, Kashif Bhatti, Mohammad Abbas, Mohammad Rizwan (wicketkeeper), Musa Khan, Nasim Shah, Shaheen Shah Afridi, Shan Masood, Yasir Shah.

© 2018 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.