Former Windies coach Simmons in the wars as Afghanistan struggles

By June 21, 2019
Phil Simmons speaking to Afghanistan players Phil Simmons speaking to Afghanistan players

Former Windies all-rounder Phil Simmons has had his ups and downs as a coach, with his latest struggles coming at the ICC World Cup in England. 

Afghanistan, his latest charges, have played five matches and lost all of them but Simmons is not taking the losses lying down, he is pointing fingers.

Simmons has seemingly fallen out with former fast bowler, Dawlat Ahmadzai.

Amadzai had been demoted from chairman of selectors to the junior selection panel midway through the World Cup.

On Wednesday, Simmons had much to say iva social media tool, Twitter, saying he would respond to statements made by Ahmadzai. Apparently, the former chief selector had blamed selection policy as well as team strategies for the team’s less-than-desirable results.

Simmons is apparently saying the former fast bowler has a part to play in those policies going awry, saying that after the World Cup, he would reveal how Ahmadzai influenced the decisions to replace Ashgar Afghan as captain with Gulbadin Naib.

According to a report on ESPNCricinfo, Simmons was never told about the impending change in captaincy and that has rubbed the former Windies all-rounder the wrong way.

"I am in the middle of a World Cup and trying to get our team to perform to the level we expect but at the end of the World Cup I will tell the Afghanistan people about the part that Mr Dawlat Ahmadzai had to play in our preparation and his part in the dismissal of #AsgharAfghan."

Simmons was responding to Asmadzai’s statements where he said "Our preparation was not good," Ahmadzai said. "We always went with one fast bowler, all burden was on the shoulders of Rashid [Khan]. But now, Rashid has no such conditions [in the UK]. If we bowl well we can win a game, but if you think we are able to win a tournament, let me assure you we are not in a position now or in coming five years to win the Asia Cup or the World Cup."

Ahmadzai, while not admitting to the changes he sought or impacted, was quick to point out that they were not personal and were for the good of Afghanistan cricket.

“Whoever is coming to replace me as a selector should think from now that in two years' time, Nabi, Hamid Hasan, Asghar, Shapoor [Zadran], Dawlat Zadran can play [at the highest level]. If they cannot do so, who should replace them? We know this and think about this. Whatever changes I brought is not personal, all these players are my personal friends of the past 17 years. We need a constructive culture. I mean, if we have one team and there is no youth, we cannot survive. Whatever right is happening, it may not sound good on media but you will see good results in time,” he said.

The latest spat, involving Simmons is interesting with rumours that the coach could be making a return to the helm of the mercurial West Indies.

Simmons had also left that job under a cloud after very public spats with the hierarchy of West Indies Cricket.

Simmons had, before the start of the World Cup, said he would not be renewing his contract with the Afghanistan side at the completion of the tournament when it would expire.

Paul-Andre Walker

Paul-Andre is the Managing Editor at He comes to the role with almost 20 years of experience as journalist. That experience includes all facets of media. He began as a sports Journalist in 2001, quickly moving into radio, where he was an editor before becoming a news editor and then an entertainment editor with one of the biggest media houses in the Caribbean.

Related items

  • Dhoni to be dropped for India, Windies tour - reports Dhoni to be dropped for India, Windies tour - reports

    India legend Mahendra Singh Dhoni is not expected to travel to the Caribbean for the team’s tour against the West Indies.

    According to reports, the team has opted to groom new wicketkeeper Rishabh Pant after Dhoni came under criticism for his performance during the ICC World Cup.

    “MS [Dhoni] will not go to the West Indies,” a source with knowledge of the situation told Times Now News said.

    “Going forward, he will not travel with the team within India or overseas as the first-choice wicketkeeper. Rishabh Pant will take over and there will be a grooming window for him until he settles down,” he added.

    “During this time, MS will help in the transition. For all you know, he could be part of the 15 but not part of the 11. This team needs a guiding hand on multiple fronts and wishing MS away is clearly unhealthy.”

    The tour will include 3 T20 Internationals, 3 ODIs and 2 test matches in the Caribbean.   The tour kicks off with the T20 internationals on August 3 and carries on until September 3, which marks the fifth day of the second test match.

  • Gower backs Jason Roy Test call-up: He is a real talent Gower backs Jason Roy Test call-up: He is a real talent

    Former England captain David Gower supports the decision to hand Jason Roy a Test call-up with the Ashes looming.

    After starring at the top of the order in his country's victorious Cricket World Cup campaign, Roy was named in England's Test squad for the first time on Wednesday, as part of a 13-man party to face Ireland at Lord's next week.

    The 28-year-old Surrey batsman, who averages 38 in first-class cricket, now looks certain to open in the first Test against Australia, starting on August 1, having earned selection through his excellent form in limited-overs cricket.

    Gower told Omnisport: "Detractors will say that Jason Roy's first-class career has been nothing like his one-day international career. I put something out on Twitter weeks ago now saying 'the talent this man is, can we not adapt him to Test cricket?'

    "There are people like David Warner who have successfully become great Test players having been one-day players; there are people like Rohit Sharma who will never play a Test match for India again despite the fact he's just got five hundreds in the World Cup, so it doesn't work for everyone.

    "But we [England] don't have particularly great alternatives. My view is that if it works it will be fantastic. If it takes a while to get going, or if it takes him a while to learn the ropes of being a Test match player, then actually we're no worse off than we are at the moment.

    "I would happily endorse him as a real talent, who with a bit of luck and hard work could knuckle down to it."

    Fast bowler Jofra Archer - another standout member of England's victorious World Cup team - has also been tipped to play a role in the Ashes, although he will miss the Test against Ireland due to a side strain.

    "Again, Jofra is an extraordinary talent, he's a brilliant talent," added Gower, a member of the England team that reached the 1979 World Cup final.

    "While one would be careful maybe about his workload, as they are about all England's bowlers, which is only sensible, again he is such a beautiful raw talent that I would have him in the side."


    - David Gower is touring theatres in October and November with his sell-out show 'On The Front Foot'. Buy your tickets from

  • Roy to make Test debut against Ireland Roy to make Test debut against Ireland

    Jason Roy is set to make his Test debut for England against Ireland, putting him in line for an Ashes call-up next month.

    Star batsman Roy is yet to feature in the longest format at international level but was vital to hosts England's Cricket World Cup triumph.

    His form in that tournament has earned him a first shot at Test cricket, selected among 13 players to face Ireland in a four-day contest at Lord's with Olly Stone and Lewis Gregory the other uncapped men to earn a spot.

    The trio are also included in a 16-man group for a pre-Ashes camp.

    There is good news for England, too, with James Anderson's inclusion in the squad, the experienced bowler having recovered from a calf tear.

    However, Jofra Archer, another waiting for a Test bow, and Mark Wood are both suffering with side strains.

    Wood is set for four to six weeks out while Archer will have a period of rest and return from Barbados later this month, with national selector Ed Smith stating the latter will be out "for a while".

    Ben Stokes and Jos Buttler - stars of the World Cup success - have also been granted leave until the pre-Ashes camp ahead of the August 1 opener.

    The four-day clash with Ireland begins on July 24.


    England squad in full for Ireland Test: Joe Root, Moeen Ali, James Anderson, Jonny Bairstow, Stuart Broad, Rory Burns, Sam Curran, Joe Denly, Lewis Gregory, Jack Leach, Jason Roy, Olly Stone, Chris Woakes.

    England squad in full for pre-Ashes camp: Moeen Ali, James Anderson, Jonny Bairstow, Stuart Broad, Rory Burns, Jos Buttler, Sam Curran, Joe Denly, Lewis Gregory, Jack Leach, Joe Root, Jason Roy, Ben Stokes, Olly Stone, Chris Woakes, Mark Wood.

© 2018 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.