Biology trumps gender identity in sport – IAAF welcomes Swiss court's Semenya ruling

By Sports Desk July 31, 2019

Caster Semenya has been denied the chance to defend her 800 metres World Athletics Championships title following a ruling by a Swiss court that has been welcomed by the IAAF.

The double Olympic champion had been given permission to race without restriction after lodging an appeal with the Federal Supreme Court of Switzerland (SFT) against the Court of Arbitration for Sport's (CAS) verdict in her case against the IAAF.

CAS ruled the IAAF could implement a regulation that would require Semenya to take medication to lower her testosterone levels to take part in women's track events ranging from 400m to a mile.

But on Tuesday a judge with the Swiss Federal Tribunal overturned the SFT's decision to allow Semenya to compete while it assessed the case in a move praised by the governing body of international athletics.

"The IAAF welcomes the Swiss Federal Tribunal's decision to revoke its Super-Provisional Order of 31 May 2019 after hearing the IAAF's arguments," a statement read.

"This decision creates much-needed parity and clarity for all athletes as they prepare for the World Championships in Doha this September.

"In the remainder of the proceedings before the SFT, the IAAF will maintain its position that there are some contexts, sport being one of them, where biology has to trump gender identity."

In her own response to the latest ruling, Semenya remained defiant.

"I am very disappointed to be kept from defending my hard-earned title, but this will not deter me from continuing my fight for the human rights of all of the female athletes concerned," she said.

Related items

  • Kipsang handed provisional suspension for alleged anti-doping rule violations Kipsang handed provisional suspension for alleged anti-doping rule violations

    Kenyan marathon runner Wilson Kipsang has been handed a provisional suspension for alleged anti-doping rule violations, the Athletics Integrity Unit (AIU) announced on Friday.

    The former world record holder has been issued with a notice of charge for whereabouts failures and tampering or attempted tampering, the AIU said on its website.

    Under World Athletics anti-doping rules, athletes must inform testing authorities of their whereabouts for one hour of every day. Three missed tests and/or filing failures within a 12-month period results in an automatic ban.

    Kipsang has triumphed at four of the six major marathons, winning twice in London along with successes in Berlin, New York and Tokyo.

    The 37-year-old won the bronze medal at the 2012 Olympics but withdrew from contention for the 2016 Rio Games.

  • Double Olympic sprint champion will be ready to defend title in 2020 Double Olympic sprint champion will be ready to defend title in 2020

    Word coming out of the MVP Track Club is that Double Olympic sprint champion, Elaine Thompson Herah, will be on the track ready to defend her title in Tokyo, Japan.

    Thompson Herah looked a certain possibility for a gold medal at last year’s IAAF World Championships of Athletics in Doha Qatar but inexplicably finished out of contention with countrywoman Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce going on to win an unprecedented fourth 100-metre world title.

    It was later explained, that an Achilles injury that had stymied too seasons for Thompson Herah, was back and the athlete was not able to generate the kinds of speeds that saw her win the National Championships in Kingston, Jamaica in a world-leading 10.72 seconds, or the Pan American Games gold medal in Lima, Peru.

    At the time, Thompson Herah’s coach, Stephen Francis, had said while the Achilles problem was a recurrent one, on this occasion, it was caused by calf tightness and that she would get over it without surgery.

    Thompson Herah still managed a fourth-place finish in Doha but had to pull out of the 200 metres, for which she had already made the semi-final. She would take no further part in the tournament.

    According to MVP Track Club President, Bruce James, who spoke to local newspaper, The Gleaner, Thompson Herah is looking better than just injury-free.

    “Elaine has returned to training and is looking set to be in fully fit form long before the Olympics in Tokyo,” said James.

    How many races it will take Thompson Herah to get back to her best is yet to be ascertained but James is still of the belief that all will be well.

    That’s not a decision that is made in January but we are just pleased to know that she’s in training and looking so good,” he said.

  • World Championship relay gold medallist already back in training after car accident World Championship relay gold medallist already back in training after car accident

    A motor vehicle accident in Florida last week has not slowed World Championship sprint relay gold medallist Jonielle Smith too much as the Jamaican is already back in training ahead of her bid to make the team to the 2020 Olympics in Tokyo, Japan.

    According to reports, the vehicle Smith was driving, was rear ended, causing a spin that led to a second collision.

    Though the car was badly damaged, it was reported that neither Smith, nor the two family members she was travelling with, were badly injured.

    Smith, a standout at high school for Wolmer’s Girls in Jamaica’s biggest track and field championships, ran the third leg on Jamaica’s gold medal 4x100-metre team at the IAAF World Championships of Athletics in Doha, Qatar last year and finished sixth in the 100-metre final there.

    Smith also recently graduated from Auburn University where she also had a more-than-creditable time on the track.

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.