TTOC believes it has good chance of overturning Ahye ban - Dave Williams

By February 13, 2020

Dave Williams, the legal advisor to the president of the Trinidad and Tobago Olympic Committee Brian Lewis, believes they have a good chance of having the Court of Arbitration for Sport overturn the two-year ban imposed on Michelle Lee Ahye for whereabouts violations.

World Athletics banned Ahye, the 2018 Commonwealth Games 100m champion on January 25, 2020, after the athlete missed three doping tests between June 23, 2018, and April 19, 2019.

However, Williams feels that there are strong grounds to have the matter overturned and clear the way for Ahye to compete at the 2020 Olympic Games in Tokyo, Japan in July.

“Having reviewed the judgment, we felt that there were grounds worthy of appeal, without going into the specifics. Additionally, the Tribunal judgment seemed quite biased as well,” he said in response to questions from Sportsmax.TV.

TTOC received the decision on January 13, 2020, and based on IAAF Anti-Doping Rules Article 13.7.1, TTOC has 30 days from the date in which it was notified of the decision (Jan, 13th) to file its Statement of Appeal (SOA).

According to Williams, the TTOC has met that deadline, however, an Appeal Brief (a more comprehensive document where the grounds, arguments, case law etc. have to be submitted) must be submitted within 15 days of the filing of the SOA.

“We are hoping for an expedited hearing, since if successful, the Athlete may be able to represent her country in Japan,” he said.

Williams said there was no official consultation with the National Association of Athletic Associations (NAAA) but indicated that they are in support of the action being taken by TTOC.

“The TTOC always seeks the best interest of its athletes and where we believe there is a chance that Michelle can be exonerated, we are prepared to assist in that regard,” Williams said.

“It is not an easy one since those rules are interpreted strictly. But such interpretation must also be fair and in keeping with the principles of natural justice. I am prepared to give it my best shot. It is not a “shot in the dark” since if viewed objectively the penalty imposed was a bit harsh, as there were mitigating circumstances that ought to have been taken into consideration.”

Leighton Levy

Leighton Levy is a journalist with 28 years’ experience covering crime, entertainment, and sports. He joined the staff at SportsMax.TV as a content editor two years ago and is enjoying the experience of developing sports content and new ideas. At SportsMax.tv he is pursuing his true passion - sports.

Related items

  • COVID-19 set to change Athletics for the next five years - Boldon COVID-19 set to change Athletics for the next five years - Boldon

    The impact of the Tokyo 2020 postponement, as well as others means track and field athletes can look forward to a tough four years to come, so says former Trinidad & Tobago sprinter and Olympic medallist Ato Boldon.

    According to Boldon, the movement of the Olympics to the Summer of 2021 is likely to push the World Championships to 2022, sparking a domino effect on other major games.

    “It means that we may be in for four championship years in a row. We know that the summer Olympics are going to be in 2021. I think they are going to push the World Championships over to 2022 which means that it then conflicts with the Commonwealth Games and the World Cup, and then we get back on stream with the regular schedule of 2023 World Championships and 2024 Olympics in Paris,” said Boldon.

    These movements, Boldon believes, won’t reset the athletic calendar for another five years, but sees no real alternative to the unprecedented action of putting an Olympics in an odd year.

    Boldon has an interest in what the next few years of athletics holds as the coach of rising star, Briana Williams.

    Williams was set to contest for a place in her first Olympics and in a recent SportsMax.tv interview, Boldon said the delay was good for his athlete, who would have a year to get stronger.

  • Opinion: Hosts keep missing the point about COVID19 Opinion: Hosts keep missing the point about COVID19

    The hosts of the various big events in the world of sports have been missing the point over and over for the last three months, much like many governments have.

    The COVID-19 Pandemic has inch by inch, ground sports to a halt all over the world and looming events have had to be either cancelled or postponed as it becomes clear that the word ‘pandemic’ is as horrifying as it sounds and the world won’t get over this issue in a few weeks or months as administrators seem to feel.

    But even more important than that, these administrators seem to feel that whether or not an event can go on, depends on the environment at the event.

    But I suggest there is more to it than that.

    The Olympics, for instance, in Tokyo, Japan, seemed to hinge on whether or not the island could get its COVID-19 problems under control before the rest of the world would travel to the event.

    When it became clear that this would not be the case, the event was postponed.

    However, up until that time, even as preparatory events for the Olympics were being cancelled and/or postponed all over the world, the International Olympic Committee had been asking athletes to prepare as if there would still be an event in July of 2020.

    That, I believe, was unfortunate, because it meant, even without travelling to meets all over the world, training was putting athletes at risk of contracting the virus.

    The danger of picking up the virus becomes even more acute when you consider team sports and how much contact it takes to get one working in unison and performing at a high level.

    For that to happen, there needs to be a combination of technical staff, trainers, teammates, and much more. That will up the chances of contracting a virus and therefore it doesn’t matter what is happening at whichever venue in the world, the athletes are at risk.

    I am acutely aware that much planning goes into putting on a large event like the Olympics or the UEFA Champions League, and that there is a lot of money riding on the event going ahead as planned.

    These considerations, I believe, make decisions grey and not as completely black and white like it might from the outside, however, sports and entertainment being the last to get on board with social distancing was, in my mind, slightly callous.

    But that’s just in my mind. These organisers may well have foreseen the financial fallout for the athletes themselves and wanted to save them, for as long as they could, from months without earning in some cases.

    Whichever way you see it, the truth is COVID-19 is likely to bankrupt far more people than it kills.

    Many of the reports on COVID-19 have also indicated that it hurts people with underlying conditions and the elderly, so the athlete with his fitness at the peak of their value, along with usually being under 40, is not in any real danger.

    But how about the person the athletes give it to? And, as was the case of 21-year-old Spanish coach, Francisco Garcia, who knows who has an underlying condition that this virus may attack?

    Garcia, a coach at Atletico Portada Alta, found out he had undiagnosed Leukemia, after being admitted to hospital with coronavirus symptoms. By then, it was too late.

    How I see it is that people and countries can recover from going broke. It happens all the time.

    I’ve never seen anybody recover from being dead.

    Cricket West Indies and the England Cricket Board are entertaining the idea of having a series between the two, scheduled for June, behind closed doors.

    Hopefully, they think better of it in short order.

  • Anna Quirot's triumph over adversity among the most compelling stories of track and field Anna Quirot's triumph over adversity among the most compelling stories of track and field

    World Athletics has named Cuba’s Ana Quirot winning gold medals at the 1995 and 1997 World Championships, among 10 of the greatest athletics moments of triumph over adversity.

© 2020 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.