JAAA president wants clarity on decision to deny Brittany Anderson gold medal

By July 17, 2018
The official photo-finish picture showing Brittany Anderson and Tori Jones tied at the finish of the 100m hurdles on Sunday. Jones was awarded the gold medal. The official photo-finish picture showing Brittany Anderson and Tori Jones tied at the finish of the 100m hurdles on Sunday. Jones was awarded the gold medal.

 President of the Jamaica Athletic Administrative Association Dr Warren Blake said he will be writing to the IAAF this week questioning the decision to deny Jamaica’s 100m hurdler Brittany Anderson a gold medal at the recently concluded World U20 Championships in Tampere, Finland.

On the final day of competition on Sunday,  July 15, Anderson crossed the line in 13.01s, the same time awarded to Tia Jones of the United States, who was awarded the gold medal. Anderson was awarded the silver medal. However, the official timing shows that both athletes had the exact same time down to the 1/1000th seconds (0.002), which according to the IAAF’s competition rules, means that both athletes are tied and that Anderson should have been awarded a gold medal.

According to IAAF Rule 167.1 and 167.2  "If the Judges or the Photo Finish Judges are unable to separate the athletes for any place according to Rules 164.2, 165.18, 165.21 or 165.24 (as may be applicable), it shall be determined to be a tie and the tie shall remain. If there is a tie for any ranking position under Rule 166.3 (b), the Chief Photo Finish Judge shall consider the actual times recorded by the athletes to .001 second and if it is equal, it shall be determined to
be a tie..."

It is against that background that Dr Blake said he is puzzled by the decision not to award Anderson, the World U18 Champion, a gold medal. Jamaica had appealed the decision at the meet but it was thrown out.

“It is crazy,” said Dr Blake, who said that the correspondence seeking clarification on the rule will be sent before the end of the week. 

“That is a question that I am going to have to ask. The irony is that same thing happened at the World Youth in Nairobi, the 400m race. Colby Jennings of the Turks and Caicos Islands and Jamaica’s Anthony Cox ran the identical time down to the thousandth of a second (46.77) yet Cox was denied the bronze medal.

“I wrote them at the World Youth about it, because they protested there and didn’t get any joy and when they looked at the thousandth it was the same and they can’t understand why. They said (IAAF) when they looked at it they could have drawn two lines between the two people. I said how can you draw two lines when they have the same time down to the thousandth and all their only response was that they could draw two lines. So this time around when I write I am going to ask them what is the criteria for awarding a first-place, second-place or whatever place.”

In the case of Brittany Anderson and Tia Jones, Dr Blake said, he didn’t see where the athletes could have been separated. “I didn’t see any double line or no double shadow but I will challenge anybody that if you have the exact same time you can’t draw two lines between them.”

Jamaica finished the championships with its best-ever medal haul – 12 medals that included four gold, five silver and three bronze medals.

 

 

 

 

 

Leighton Levy

Leighton Levy is a journalist with 28 years’ experience covering crime, entertainment, and sports. He joined the staff at SportsMax.TV as a content editor two years ago and is enjoying the experience of developing sports content and new ideas. At SportsMax.tv he is pursuing his true passion - sports.

Related items

  • Usain Bolt to feature in Tokyo 2020 stadium inauguration Usain Bolt to feature in Tokyo 2020 stadium inauguration

    Japan will be opening a brand new National Stadium for the 2020 Olympics in Tokyo on December 21 and former sprinter, the world’s fastest ever man, Jamaica’s Usain Bolt will be headlining its launch.

    While the details are still sketchy, Bolt is expected to be running again in “a new type of race that has never existed before.”

    Bolt, the world record holder over 100 and 200 metres, made the Olympics his stage when he won both events in Beijing in 2008, in London in 2012, and in Rio in 2016.

    Bolt will be joined by Japanese performing arts group Kodo.

    Also part of the inauguration will be the Tohoku Kizuna festival.

    The New National Stadium will host the opening and closing ceremonies of the 2020 Olympics, as well as athletics and football tournaments at throughout. It will also host the Paralympics.

    The first official sports event at the stadium will be the Japanese emperor’s cup on January 1, 2020.

  • JADCO to proceed with defamation lawsuit against Dr. Emir Crowne JADCO to proceed with defamation lawsuit against Dr. Emir Crowne

    Lawyers representing the Jamaica Anti-Doping Commission (JADCO) are proceeding to initiate legal action against noted attorney Dr Emir Crowne after the latter refused to apologize for alleged defamatory comments he made about the commission in  August this year.

  • IAAF president dubs post-Bolt World Champs the best in history IAAF president dubs post-Bolt World Champs the best in history

    IAAF President Sebastian Coe has described the IAAF World Athletics Championships Doha 2019 as the best in history in terms of the quality and depth of performances produced by the athletes of more than 200 nations.

    Speaking after the final evening session last Sunday, Coe noted that six championship records had been set, 43 countries had won medals, and athletes from 68 different nations had achieved at least one top-eight placing. There have been 21 area records – double the number from 2017 – and 86 national records have been broken, underlining the global reach of the sport.

    “For those who follow our sport closely, you will know that we rank our championships on the performances of the athletes,” Coe said. “It is how we, the athletes and the coaches measure our success.

    “The world’s athletes have put on the best show in the history of the IAAF World Athletics Championships, according to the competition performance rankings which are used as an objective measure of the quality of international competition.

    “These performances are incredible but credit must also go to the facilities and conditions provided by the host country. Doha has created conditions on the field of play and in the warm up that are unsurpassed.

    “We are proud of the fact we reach more countries than any other sport,” added Coe. “Just look at the breadth and depth – 43 countries on the medals table and 86 national records set. We want our athletes to experience different cultures and different conditions. It’s what makes our sport so accessible.”

    Dahlan Al Hamad, Vice President of the local organising committee, was delighted to see Qatar’s dreams become reality.

    “Our dream started in 1997 when we organised the first meeting in this stadium,” he said. “After that, we kept hosting many meets until 2000 when we organised the Grand Prix Final. We continued our journey in 2010 when we organised the World Indoor Championships in the nearby Aspire Dome. We also organised the Diamond League meeting here and it was really good.

    “We are thrilled we have been able to expand. There are generations here who are hungry to have this kind of sporting event here. Qatar is a nation of more than 100 communities. They have been able to celebrate their athletes from all around the world.”

     

    Top ranked World Championships

    Based on the IAAF competition performance rankings, used to rank the quality of competitions, the IAAF World Athletics Championships Doha 2019 tops the list of all World Championships to date.

     

    Taking the best five results and athletes from the best 24 events, the top five editions are:

     

    1. 2019, Doha – 195,869
    2. 2015, Beijing – 194,547
    3. 2017, London – 193,426
    4. 2013, Moscow – 192,664
    5. 2009, Berlin – 191,168

     

    Based on the average scores of all track and field results, the top five editions are:

     

    1. 2019, Doha – 1024.75
    2. 2017, London – 1012.84
    3. 1999, Seville – 1007.98
    4. 2015, Beijing – 1004.78
    5. 2009, Berlin – 1004.55

     

    There have been many outstanding performances over the 10 days of competition with unprecedented depth in many of the finals. Based on the IAAF scoring tables, the top five men’s and women’s performances are:

     

    MEN

    22.91m Joe Kovacs (USA) shot put – 1295pts

    22.90m Tom Walsh (NZL) shot put – 1294pts

    22.90m Ryan Crouser (USA) shot put – 1294pts

    9.76 Christian Coleman (USA) 100m – 1291pts

    43.48 Steven Gardiner (BAH) 400m – 1289pts

     

    WOMEN

    7.30m Malaika Mihambo (GER) long jump – 1288pts

    48.14 Salwa Eid Naser (BRN) 400m – 1281pts

    48.37 Shaunae Miller-Uibo (BAH) 400m – 1272pts

    3:51.95 Sifan Hassan (NED) 1500m – 1271pts

    6981 Katarina Johnson-Thompson (GBR) heptathlon – 1269pts

     

    The championships have not just been about record-breaking performances, though. This edition will also be remembered for its close finishes, surprise winners, moments of fair play, and the arrival of the next generation of athletics stars.

    USA’s 200m winner Noah Lyles and Germany’s decathlon victor Niklas Kaul became the youngest ever world champions in their respective events. Ukraine’s Yaroslava Mahuchikh twice broke the world U20 record on her way to the silver medal in the high jump. She was one of several athletes born in or after the year 2000 who earned medals, along with Ethiopian duo Selemon Barega and Lemecha Girma and Bahrain’s Musa Isah.

    The innovations – including light shows, new camera angles and increased engagement with athletes – have helped the sport reach a younger audience around the world.

© 2018 SportsMaxTV All Rights Reserved.